What is the difference between hammer crusher and impact crusher? how to choose?
Customer Cases
# What is the Difference Between Hammer Crusher and Impact Crusher? How to Choose?
When it comes to breaking down materials in mining and construction, the choice between a hammer crusher and an impact crusher can be crucial. Each crusher serves a specific function and has its own advantages and disadvantages. Understanding the differences will help you make an informed decision that will maximize efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and productivity.
## Key Differences Between Hammer Crusher and Impact Crusher
### 1. **Operating Principle**
- **Hammer Crusher**: Operates with high-speed hammer impacts to crush the material. The rotor is equipped with hammers that swing freely, creating kinetic energy that deals crushing blows to the feed material. It primarily handles material through collision.
- **Impact Crusher**: Utilizes impact rather than pressure. Material is fed into a chamber containing a high-speed rotor, where it is accelerated and thrown against a stationary impact wall (the breaker plate). As the material rebounds, it continues to be impacted by the rotor and the impact wall until it's crushed to the desired size.
### 2. **Material Suitability**
- **Hammer Crusher**: Ideal for hard, abrasive materials such as limestone, coal, gypsum, and shale. It is efficient for feed sizes up to 1200 mm, providing a reduction ratio up to 20:1.
- **Impact Crusher**: More versatile and suitable for a wider range of materials, including softer, less abrasive substances like limestone, concrete, and recycled asphalt. It typically allows for feed sizes up to 300 mm and offers a reduction ratio of up to 20:1.
### 3. **Final Product Quality**
- **Hammer Crusher**: Produces more fine material and less powder with a higher reduction ratio. This can be advantageous when a high volume of fine output is required.
- **Impact Crusher**: Provides a higher quality of material with more uniform particles. The cubic-shaped, uniform-sized output is ideal for use in road construction and other applications.
### 4. **Maintenance and Operating Costs**
- **Hammer Crusher**: Generally requires more frequent maintenance due to the mechanical wear on the hammers and grate bars. This can increase long-term operational costs.
- **Impact Crusher**: Typically requires less maintenance due to a less aggressive operating mechanism, potentially lowering overall costs over the lifespan of the equipment.
## How to Choose Between Hammer Crusher and Impact Crusher
### Consider the Following Factors:
1. **Material Characteristics**: Evaluate the hardness, abrasiveness, and moisture content of the material you are processing. Hammer crushers excel with hard, dry materials while impact crushers handle more moisture and varied materials.
2. **Desired Product Size and Shape**: Determine the final product requirements. If you need a more uniform shape with less fines, the impact crusher is the better option.
3. **Production Requirements**: Assess the production capacity needed. Hammer crushers generally accommodate larger feed sizes and produce more fines, suitable for high-volume needs.
4. **Cost and Efficiency**: Analyze your budget for initial purchase and ongoing maintenance. While hammer crushers might be less expensive initially, the cost of wear parts and repairs can add up over time compared to an impact crusher.
5. **Specific Applications**: Consider the specific use case. Construction and roadwork demand different material characteristics than mining, which can influence your choice based on project needs.
### Conclusion
Selecting the right crusher is crucial for optimizing efficiency, product quality, and operational costs. By considering the differences in operating principles, material suitability, product quality, and maintenance, you can make an informed choice between a hammer crusher and an impact crusher. Remember to weigh your priorities in terms of material characteristics, desired product outcome, and budget constraints to arrive at the best decision for your project needs.
Online Chat
Sales Hotline